 |
K. O. Sorokina, V. A. Fedorenko Estimation of the Optimal Criterion for Matching Coinciding Stria in Marks of Rifling Lands |
 |
|
Abstract.
Algorithms for automatic comparison of the traces of the rifling lands (secondary toolmarks) are currently under active development. The calculation of a quantitative estimate based on the results of the comparison of the similarity of the traces of the rifling lands is also being investigated. Determining the optimal criterion for categorizing striae as "matching" in coincident secondary toolmarks is an actual problem. Our studies have shown that assigning traces to the "matching" class can be performed using Shannon information entropy. In this case, the Shannon entropy is used to estimate the criterion of optimal striae intersection. To carry out a model experiment, a sample of 344 pairs of obviously matching and 344 pairs of obviously non-matching secondary toolmarks was formed. On its basis, 200 validation subsamples were formed. The realizations characterized by the lowest entropy were calculated for each criterion of striae overlap in width (10%-100%, 20%-100%, ..., 100%) for all subsamples. It was shown that for secondary toolmarks on bullets fired from a Makarov pistol, this criterion is the interval of striae overlaps in width from 60% to 100%.
Keywords:
traces of rifling lands, matching striae, Shannon entropy, validation.
PP. 50-58.
DOI 10.14357/20718632230105 References
1. Tipovye ekspertnye metodiki issledovaniia veshchestvennykh dokazatel'stv. Ch.1., Pod redaktsiei Iu.M.Dil'dina. [Typical Expert Methods of Examination of Physical Evidence. Part 1, Under the editorship of Yu.M. Dildin]. Moscow: INTERKRIM-PRESS, 2010, pp. 72-81. 2. Fedorenko V.A., Myl'tsina O.A. 2016. Kontseptsiia matematicheskoi modeli otsenki unikal'nosti naborov sovpadaiushchikh trass vo vtorichnykh sledakh na vystrelennykh puliakh [The concept of a mathematical model for estimating the uniqueness of sets of matching striae in the secondary toolmarks on the fired bullets]. Izvestiia Saratovskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta. Novaia seriia. Ekonomika. Upravlenie. Pravo [Proceedings of Saratov State University. New series. Economics. Management. Law.]. 16(2):209-213. 3. Fedorenko V. A., Navrotskaya E. V. 2019. Kriterii i algoritm otsenki unikal'nosti kompleksov sovpadayushchikh trass v sledakh na vystrelennykh pulyakh. [Criteria and algorithm for evaluating the uniqueness of complexes of matching tracks in traces on fired bullets]. Informatsionnye tekhnologii i vychislitel'nye sistemy [Information Technologies and computing systems]. 1:110-120. 4. Biasotti A. 1959. A Statistical Study of the Individual Characteristics of Fired Bullets. Journal Forensic Sciences. 4 (1):34–50. 5. Chen Z., Chu W., Soons J. A., Thompson R. M., Song J., Zhao X. 2019. Fired bullet signature correlation using the Congruent Matching Profile Segments (CMPS) method. Forensic Science International. 305:10-19. 6. Chen Z., Song J., Soons J. A., Thompson R. M., Zhao X. 2020. Pilot study on deformed bullet correlation. Forensic Science International. 306:1-11. 7. Eric Hare, Heike Hofmann, Alicia Carriquiry, Automatic Matching of Bullet Land // The Annals of Applied Statistics, 2017, Vol. 11, No. 4, 2332–2356 https://doi.org/10.1214/17-AOAS1080 8. Eric Hare, Heike Hofmann, Alicia Carriquiry, Algorithmic Approaches to Match Degraded Land Impressions // Law Probability and Risk. December 2017. 9. The IBIS Solution https://www.ultraforensictechnology. com/en/products-and-services/firearmand- tool-mark-identification-ibisr/the-ibisr-solutionintegrated- ballistic-identification-system дата обращения 12.12.2022 г. 10. https://wiki.loginom.ru/articles/inform-entropy.html дата обращения15 декабря 2022 г.
|
